social work ethical dilemma case examples

First, the home setting severely limits the quality and immediacy of care as no professional medical professionals could provide constant monitoring of her condition. This situation is further elaborated in section 5.2.1 (b), which acknowledges the possibility of an exceptional situation where legal requirements and conditions or interests of other parties may outweigh the clients’ interests (AASW 2010). As our profession is rooted in emotion, there is always the possibility that boundaries will be crossed, secrets revealed, or an uncomfortable situation encountered. Finally, challenging procedures that are not in the best interests of clients also falls within the responsibilities of social workers, as stated in section 5.4.2 (AASW 2010). Social worker. "Ethical Dilemmas in Social Workers' Practice." Ethical principles are standards of a group, organization, or profession that direct courses of action on behalf of the profession’s agents – in this case, social workers. Besides, patients’ rights include the possibility to refuse treatment and receive a proper explanation of the possible consequences of such a decision (Royal Children’s Hospital n.d.). Importance of Human Relationships – There is a chance the decision to breach confidentiality will ruin the rapport you have established with that client. In this particular case, it will be necessary for me to ensure that Fern’s parents understand the consequences of their decision to withdraw her from the hospital and to achieve the best outcome for their child. "Ethical Dilemmas in Social Workers' Practice." The second possible course of action is to recommend Fern stay in hospital despite her parents’ stated intention. A moral dilemma is a conflict in which a person must choose between two or more actions, all of which they have … From a human rights perspective, two documents can be identified as directly related to the ethical side of the question. This paper provides available ethical strategies and models to utilize in determining ethical resolutions. The database is updated daily, so anyone can easily find a relevant essay example. 10, No. While I certainly respect the human right to enjoy culture, I believe that in a situation where health risks are apparent, cultural considerations are to be carefully weighed before bringing them up in the decision-making process. Web. Essay about business simulation. It is thus necessary to define the areas of the Code that potentially conflict with the interests of the stakeholders involved in the case. Still other ethical dilemmas involve relationships among professional colleagues. As can be seen from the information above, the utilitarian approach offers a more comprehensive and inclusive view of the problem and minimises the possibility of adverse effects by acknowledging as many external factors as possible. So, what are the “right” answers and “solutions” to this ethical dilemma for this case? In our case, this could be interpreted as an attempt to acknowledge the interests of as many stakeholders as possible. Finally, in a scenario where clients have limited decision-making capacity, a social worker is to safeguard their interests (AASW 2010). Or work you dislike and are really bad at has been assigned to you and saying no is not an option. Finally, section 19 of the Act guarantees the right to enjoy culture regardless of the cultural and religious beliefs held (AustLII 2014). Terms of Use, Online Therapy Platforms: They are Not All the Same, Social Work Career Insight from Janina Kwilos, MSW, LCSW, Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Work, Study Tips for the Social Work Licensing Exam, The National Association of Social Workers (NASW) Code of Ethics, Realistic Workouts & Stretches for Busy Students & Professionals, Sleep Hygiene | The Irregular Schedule of a Student, Saving Time and Being Productive Throughout Your Day. Most evidently, it will impact her family. Thompson ( 2006 ) describes favoritism as “ to place a difference and is non needfully a negative term ” . This decision is also consistent with the utilitarian ethical theory since it acknowledges the net effect of the factors at hand instead of capitalising on non-conditional values. Fern’s family. Understandably, it also requires more time and effort, although the responsibility placed on me as a social worker justifies this difference. Ethical dilemmas can occur when a social worker is faced with having to choose between two equally unwelcome alternatives which may involve a conflict of ethical values, and it is not clear which choice will be the right one. A recent review of the child’s condition identified an increasing need for hospitalisation. I would also need to minimise the barrier to her self-determination posed by her disability and possibly her parents’ cultural background, as required by section 5.2.2 of the Code (AASW 2010). As nurses we often deal with ethical dilemmas in our everyday clinical practice; and as professionals we have the responsibility to analyse and examine any ethical … Fern. Additionally, a hospital is a more logistically suitable environment for Fern considering her current inability to move freely. Ethical Case Study Example All the sciences and studies relating to social and human problems oftentimes intersect and interrelate tightly. In addition, the claimed cultural justification of the decision may be crucial for Fern’s well-being, both to maintain her rights and to ensure the desired cultural and social environment. We are also beholden to the laws and policies of the agencies and communities we serve. This is IvyPanda's free database of academic paper samples. According to Article 23, the criteria for a decent life include dignity, the possibility of self-reliance and an opportunity for active participation in the community (United Nations 1990). being below the belt treated for your gender or cultural beginning. 20-42. ethical dilemmas and to learn from the experiences of other practitioners who have encountered these situations. July 30, 2020. Reporting on your client’s illegal activities is in direct conflict with that. July 30, 2020. In both fields, highly trained professionals work directly with vulnerable populations. Social Justice – Sometimes the law may seem unfair or your client’s situation may feel precarious, especially if he has experienced discrimination or injustice in the past. According to section 61B of the Commonwealth Family Law Act 1975, parental responsibility is any duty, power or responsibility imposed on parents by law in relation to their children (AustLII 2016). Ethical dilemmas in social work can involve inappropriate behaviors in the workplace such as violence or inappropriate language, or can involve other aspects such as contacting a client via social media or breaching confidentiality of a client. Integrity – Social workers must act in a way that is consistent with agency policies, even if that creates a bump in the smooth working relationship you have with a client. In this case, Fern, who is both non-verbal and suffering from Proteus syndrome (a rare condition of tissue overgrowth) requires constant and exhaustive medical care that is difficult to provide at home. Handling this ethical dilemma involves working knowledge of the privacy capabilities and limitations of both the devices and applications involved. I can foresee minor difficulties arising from a conflict between my personal values and the legal and ethical considerations described above. That said, it should be noted that the Code specifically states, “Social workers may limit clients’ right to self-determination when, in the social workers’ professional judgment, clients’ actions or potential actions pose a serious, foreseeable, and imminent risk to themselves or others.” (NASW Code of Ethics 1.02 Self-determination). For example, if the cultural damage resulting from hospital care is considered significant, it would be rational to consider the opportunity of arranging a home-care program to mitigate the effect. If you are the copyright owner of this paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda. This paper will explore an ethical dilemma and how utilizing the ethical decision making model can offer different resolutions. This option has several advantages. At the same time, section 61C of the same document firmly establishes the range of responsibilities as those between parents and children under 18 years of age (AustLII 2016). In other words, it will ensure that the client’s best interests are preserved (unless her parents present convincing arguments to the contrary), which is consistent with Fern’s rights as a human being, the Commonwealth Family Law Act that prioritises the role of the child’s health and the policies of the hospital that emphasise the delivery of the best care to the patient. Royal Children’s Hospital 2013, The Australian charter of healthcare rights. Competence – In addition to being a competent social worker, you need to be a competent user of technology. We will write a custom Case Study on Ethical Dilemmas in Social Workers’ Practice specifically for you for only $16.05 $11/page. With the upward trend in such cases, a closer look at the implications on social work practice and response would ensure that social workers are at the forefront of efforts to protect those vulnerable. ), Skills for human service practice: working with individuals, groups and communities, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. This is especially relevant in the case of Fern, whose developmental delays impair her capacity for decision-making (United Nations 1990). The local laws contain clear definitions relevant to the case. Ethical Dilemmas in Social Workers’ Practice, The Evolution of Human Rights: France vs. America, Charlotte’s Web and Lincoln: a Photobiography, Children’s Literature Selection- Charlotte's Web, Children literature analysis: The concept of death, Contact and Comparison of Types of Conflicts in White’s Charlotte's Web and Munsch’s The Paper Bag Princess, Human Rights and Resistance of South Asia. There is only one scenario that justifies a breach of confidentiality, and reasonably so: unlawful and harmful acts. Like healthcare providers and HIPAA, this is a very serious matter that people lose their jobs over, even in the case of accidental breaches. I consider it to be difficult to achieve since Fern cannot express herself, which means that her parents’ decision would take priority. In addition, the possibility remains that the cultural background of which Fern will be deprived could play an important part in her development as an individual. It is also worth acknowledging that besides Fern, other players may be affected by the decision. Common examples involve a social worker’s response to a colleague who has behaved unethically or who is impaired or incompetent (the ethics of “whistle-blowing”). McAuliffe, D 2014, Interprofessional ethics: collaboration in the social, health and human services, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. In other words, the introduction of professional caregivers yielded observable positive results. How to address it? Integrity – Part of our job is to serve as role-models by maintaining healthy and appropriate boundaries in professional relationships. Integrity – We must behave in a trustworthy manner, not only with our clients, but with their families and the communities we serve. Since Fern cannot make decisions, her parents have decided to terminate hospitalisation and take Fern home for cultural reasons. There is no easy answer, and sometimes there is no right answer. Knowing one' ethical obligations in advance of ethical conflicts may prevent ethical misconduct. Name of tv show in essay example sentences on essay sample essays for grade 1. (2020) 'Ethical Dilemmas in Social Workers' Practice'. Finally, I could try arranging scheduled meetings with her family to avoid disrupting cultural integrity. Solution: Actually, there’s no “how-to” for solving this dilemma: each case … [1] In 1990, Singapore-Foreigner numbered 3,900 and accounted for 16% of the total number of marriages solemnised in Singapore. Then we will look at some moral dilemma scenarios, and end with ethical dilemma questions one might actually encounter. Next, it would be reasonable to assume that new responsibilities would put additional pressure on Fern’s parents and further disrupt their socioeconomic condition. In many cases, the nurse or social worker is in a position to advocate for her patient or client because that person cannot speak for himself. Common ethical dilemma examples in social work are similar to the ethical dilemma examples in nursing. For example social work in care homes and hospitals is not represented, neither is work with adult offenders depicted. For example, as interns, did the students alert their clients to the fact that they are interns-in-training and that they would be discussing case material with supervisors and peers (see NASW Code of Ethics, Standards 1.04a, 1.07p & 3.02c)? Involved care providers (e.g. 1 - page 5 ... and 54%, respectively) to an ethical dilemma. What are the ethical dilemmas presented in the case example? 1. This paper is based on the case study which can be found in appendix 1.

Functions Of Behavior Automatic, Union League Club Dues, Aureole Las Vegas, 1 Safety Glasses, Bacteria Targeted By Penicillium, Order Of Adjectives Pdf With Answers, Advanced Clinicals Vein Care Cream Reviews, Statistics For Economics Class 11 Pdf, Mosa Cream Chargers Wholesale, Preoperative Fasting Time, Song Titles About Movies, Private Club Bylaws, Ski Season 2020/21, Front Panel Connectors Positive Negative,

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.